Clipess or Flat Pedals - Which is Best?

04/04/2019

Whether you’re new to mountain biking or a seasoned expert, you’ve probably pondered the benefits of using clipless pedals versus flat pedals. There are many opinions about which one is the right choice, but like many component questions, it isn’t a matter of asking which is best but which is best for you

 

file

 

When shopping for pedals, ask yourself what kind of rider you are and what type of terrain you typically ride. Shimano offers a wide range of both SPD “clipless” pedals and flat pedals that meet the demands of all kinds of riders. Whether you want pedals with a larger platform and long pins to hold your foot in place or a minimalistic design that sheds mud quickly, Shimano pedals set the benchmark in performance. 

 

What’s the difference between flat and clipless pedals?

Flat pedals are sometimes called platform pedals and provide a wide, flat area for your feet. While you can use these pedals with normal shoes, many flat pedals users prefer mountain bike specific shoes with sticky rubber soles to improve grip. Shimano takes this one step further with flat pedal and shoe designs that work together as a system, providing a larger interface between the pedal and shoe while optimizing grip.

 

The term “clipless pedal” is a bit of a misnomer and can be confusing to new cyclists. Clipless pedals work together with cycling-specific shoes that have cleats bolted to the soles. When you step onto the pedal, the cleat clips into a spring-loaded mechanism in the pedal for a secure attachment between your shoe and the bike. With an easy twist of your heel to the side, the cleat and pedal release and your foot is free.

 

So why are pedals that you step or “clip” into called “clipless”? In the early days of the cycling, many riders used flat pedals with metal or plastic cages at the front of the pedal that held the rider’s foot in place. Straps were used to tighten the cages down over the user’s feet and these pedals were commonly referred to as “tow-clips.” They were difficult to get into and out of while riding, leading to the development of the pedals known today as clipless. 

 

What type of mountain bike pedal is best for beginners?

file

 

Mountain biking is already an intimidating sport. If you’re just getting started, consider using platform pedals so you can easily hop on and off your bike or put a foot down without worrying about unclipping your foot. Spend time building your confidence and handling skills before considering a switch to clipless pedals. 

 

The right pedal for the right kind of riding

Choosing between clipless pedals and flat pedals mostly comes down to feel. Many riders prefer clipless pedals because they provide a more secure and powerful feel when pedaling hard. You can pull up as well as push down through the pedal stroke, delivering more power and making the most of your efforts, particularly when climbing. This is the reason you don’t see cross-country racers using flats pedals.

 

On the flipside, many mountain bikers choose to use flat pedals because there are times when you don’t want a mechanical connection to your bike. Dirt jumpers and bike park riders and some downhill racers stick to flat pedals. 

 

How to choose flat pedals

Flat pedals come in a variety of sizes, shapes, and materials. More aggressive riders like downhill racers and free-riders prioritize durability and security over weight savings. Shimano SAINT PD-M828 flat pedals feature a wide platform with 12 stainless-steel pins along the edges and in the center for optimal grip on gnarly terrain. 

 

The versatile DEORE XT PD-M8040 flat pedals are the choice pedal of many trail and Enduro riders. Offered in two sizes, small-medium and medium-large, they deliver optimal support and performance with the best balance of weight and durability across all riding conditions.   

 

file

How to choose clipless pedals

Clipless pedals are designed for the many different styles of mountain biking. While all SPD clipless pedals feature a similar clipless mechanism, they can differ in construction materials, weight, and complexity of the pedal design. Shimano has a variety of different SPD mountain bike pedals to choose from based on the type of riding you plan to do.

 

Cross country riders opt for lightweight pedal with a minimalistic design. The new XTR PD-M9100 cross-country pedals have a sleek construction and weigh just 310 grams. They also offer adjustable spring tension, which allows riders to fine tune the amount of force required to clip in and out of the pedals. 

 

Pedals designed for general trail riding and Enduro racing often have larger bodies to protect the clipless mechanism from damage. Shimano offers a trail configuration of both the XT and XTR pedals for more aggressive riding. The larger cage protects the clipless mechanism while also offering an expanded shoe-pedal contact area for added stability on technical terrain. 

 

file

 

Gravity and downhill riders choose more robust SPD pedals like Shimano’s alloy bodied SAINT PD-M820 pedals. These resemble flat pedals with a wide platform but they include a clipless mechanics for a solid interface between shoe and pedal. The wider surface supports soft-soled gravity shoes and gives riders a secure platform in the event they come unclipped.

 

Shimano Mountain Bike Flat Pedal Line-Up

Shimano Mountain Bike SPD Pedal Line-Up